How to define machine breakdown causes?

To quote Marshall McLuhan, the man who predicted the Internet: “We shape our tools, and afterwards the tools shape us”. When using a system or a tool to monitor machine downtime, performance and OEE automatically, the outcome usually depends on how well your system is set up. Defining machine breakdown causes is one of the most important tasks to do.

This article will look at the most critical aspects you need to focus on. You can apply these ideas, whether you are using Evocon or if you want to improve your current process of machine downtime tracking.

Building a framework for useful machine downtime analysis

The first thing to think about is the structure of your machine breakdown causes and the best way to make this. You also want to keep it as simple as possible so that production operators on the shop floor can easily find the exact reasons. To get started with this, put together the most frequent breakdown reasons in your production and see how you can group them.

Grouping machine breakdown causes

The standard practice is to start with three to five groups, and each group should have no more than six breakdown causes. Six is the optimal figure as it helps keep the list short and manageable. But we also have users who successfully manage up to eight stop reasons per group. By no means is this wrong, it just means more scrolling, more complexity, and spending more time on finding the right reason for your operators. But sometimes, depending on the production process, this is justified as it adds more insight to production downtime analysis.

Avoiding generalisation

When you define machine breakdown causes, then we strongly recommend to avoid definitions that are too general. The reason is very simple – if your causes are general, then so is your downtime analysis. And you are not able to make informed decisions on what to improve in order to increase OEE and reduce downtime.

For example, let’s look at a breakdown cause, called “Mechanical breakdown”. If your operators register this reason 30 times per month and you forward the problem to your maintenance team, then there is not much they can do with this information. But if you use more specific reasons, such as “Conveyor breakdown” or “Packing machine breakdown” then it gives a much more detailed understanding of the problems with machinery. And your maintenance team can be more effective in solving problems.

How to handle infrequent breakdowns?

Once you have your main stop groups and reasons defined, you are already much better off than most manufacturers. But in addition to the most frequent stop reasons, sometimes rare breakdowns occur. And it is essential to keep track of those as well because they can give you precious information about your production.

There are different ways that you can keep track of these reasons. If you use Evocon, then we recommend creating a breakdown group called “Other” or to define a cause called “Other” in one of the existing groups. Furthermore, in Evocon, operators can add extra notes to all breakdown reasons. These notes can often reveal crucial details about your downtime. Either way, you should periodically go over these reasons and see if there are any patterns and if you need to add a new breakdown cause to your list.

For example, if after analysing the “Other” reason you see that operators have entered reasons such as: “Material shortage”, “No Material” and “Material missing”. Then it probably means that you should include in your list of reasons a breakdown that is related to the shortage of material. If you do this, then be sure to communicate the change to all the people on the shop floor, so they know that the list of breakdown causes has been updated.

Registering breakdown causes on long production lines

Monitoring the breakdown causes of long production lines can sometimes be tricky. The difficulties may arise from the fact that only a few production operators are managing the whole line or that only one part of the whole line has a system in place that automatically monitors breakdowns.

Thus if your operator is stationed at the end of the line and the line stops because there was a breakdown at the beginning of the line, you need the data to reflect this.

In Evocon, this is solved by using a feature called “Locations”. This gives you the possibility to define all the different parts of your production line. If you have done this, then all you operators have to do is just include this piece of information when choosing the correct cause and group.

An excellent example of this is the food and beverages industry, where bottling lines are ubiquitous. Typical locations on these lines include conveyor-in, filling, capping, labelling, conveyor-out. Once you have these locations defined in Evocon, then everything becomes easy. If there is a conveyor breakdown, then all your operators have to do is choose the correct machine breakdown cause – conveyor breakdown – and the location – conveyor-in.

Using this feature will significantly enhance the way you analyse your production downtime because it immediately adds an extra layer of transparency to the data that you collect.

Sample breakdown causes to help you get started

To help you get started, we have put together an example list of the different machine breakdown causes that you can use. This information is based on our users that come from a wide variety of various industries.

Here are examples of different stop groups and reasons that can help you build a framework for effective machine downtime analysis:

  • Setup
    • Product changeover
    • Measure change
    • Material change
    • Setup
  • Technical
    • Machine reset
    • Conveyor breakdown
    • Robot breakdown
    • Aspiration failure
    • Power failure
    • Lubrication failure
  • Work arrangement
    • Material shortage/waiting
    • Material poor quality
    • Forklift wait/bringing material/taking material away
    • Supplies missing/searching/waiting
    • Work on another machine
    • Work order/working instruction missing
  • Maintenance
    • Cleaning the machine
    • Daily maintenance
    • Weekly maintenance
    • Planned maintenance
    • Unplanned maintenance
    • Cleaning
  • Planned stops
    • Pause
    • Lunch
    • Meeting
    • Training session

Avoid overthinking and start monitoring

There is one key thing to take away from here – avoid overthinking. Because you probably have an idea already what the most frequent breakdown causes are in your production. So get your team together, define the reasons together and look at it as a continuous improvement process.

Once you have your groups and causes identified, you are ready to start monitoring your breakdowns. Be sure to read our article on “How to start with production downtime analysis?” so you can get the most out of your production data.

And if you need help defining your breakdown causes or your looking for recommendations, then contact our team, and we will be more than happy to help you.